Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Natasha's avatar

ian, your comments here have been disingenuous, and you have failed to honestly and logically address the issues I have raised, giving the distinct impression your main aim in engaging here is to antagonise and irritate, not to genuinely learn or understand. So I'm now giving up on any further attempts trying to communicate with you.

Indeed I have written my comments not for you, but for other future readers of this comments section.

PS and please don't pretend that barging into a Catholic seminary is even remotely analogous to someone wanting to take a piss in toilet: if a Jewish person converts to Catholicism they will be admitted to seminaries, whereas under your "gender critical" ideology you would NEVER admit a trans or intersex person into what you dictate is the 'wrong' changing room or bog!

Further "When it comes to attending a church service, many​ people might wonder if‍ they are welcome to simply walk in off the street. The short answer is: yes! Most churches are open‍ to visitors ⁤and newcomers, regardless of their background or beliefs."

https://westernchurch.net/churches/casual-church-visit-can-i-just-walk-into-a-church/

Indeed you advocate for PERMANENTLY and LEGALLY forcing the exclusion of 0.5% of the UK population from enjoying the same freedoms and legal protections enjoyed by the remaining 99.5%, based upon an anti-scientific ideology [that "biological sex" is binary, thus ignoring intersex people] and fear mongering based upon a tiny sample of criminals already in prisons, convicted for crimes far worse than pissing or changing in the 'wrong' room.

Further still: "Transgender individuals show brain-structural alterations that differ from their biological sex as well as their perceived gender."

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41386-020-0666-3

"These findings add support to the notion that the underlying brain anatomy in transgender people is shifted away from their biological sex towards their gender identity."

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8955456/

Expand full comment
ian's avatar

The law cannot be based on what are rare medical conditions. like disordered sexual development. For the vast majority of the population, if someone with XY chromosomes and normal physiology, goes through puberty, then there are permanent mental and physiological changes that cannot be changed no matter how much surgery or hormone treatment are given later. There should be no question of them entering female prisons, changing rooms, or competing as women in sport,

Expand full comment
29 more comments...

No posts